When learning about orchestral conductors of previous generations, discographies—their audible, recorded legacies—are a natural place to begin. Always an incomplete picture, that legacy is especially lacking for many podium masters of the early 20th century. At first glance, Serge Koussevitzky’s discography with the Boston Symphony Orchestra looks impressive for its quantity and depth, but its scope is all the more amazing when one considers that his commercial recordings were made in only fifteen of the conductor’s twenty-five seasons as conductor and music director of the BSO.
No recordings survive in any form from the first four seasons (1924-28) of Koussevitzky’s tenure with the BSO. Although the orchestra began recording by mechanical means in 1917, it was one of the last major American orchestras to make its first electrical recordings in November 1928. The Depression created a pause in record making from 1930 to 1934. The actions of the American Federation of Musicians union prevented any recording activity from March 1940 until November 1944, so the Koussevitzky-BSO discography forms three periods: 1928-1930, 1934-1940, and 1944-1950.
The discography features many items of great historic value, both for the music itself but also as an illustration of the range of Koussevitzky’s interests. Of special importance was his commitment to new music, particularly that of American composers. Included in this trove of remasters are premiere recordings, some of which were arguably never surpassed in terms of artistic fidelity, of music by some of the greatest living composers of the era, including the Russians Sergei Prokofiev and Dmitri Shostakovich and the Americans Aaron Copland, Roy Harris, Howard Hanson, Randall Thompson, and Walter Piston. There are a great many works that were outside of the familiar repertoire of the time, such as Mozart’s symphonies nos. 26, 29, 33, and 34, Haydn’s 92 and 102, and J.S. Bach’s Brandenburg Concertos and Orchestral Suites. While most recordings were made at Boston’s Symphony Hall under studio conditions, two major works—J.S. Bach’s St. Matthew Passion and Beethoven’s Missa Solemnis—were recorded live in concert. Roy Harris’s Symphony 1933 was recorded live in New York’s Carnegie Hall.
It isn’t just the repertoire that makes the recordings of Koussevitzky and the Boston Symphony so compelling. Every release shows an orchestra of the very first rank; indeed, the BSO was considered the finest in the world after World War II. Virtuosity is a given, but these recordings, especially in the later ones, present a tonal palette of wonderful variety. More than a few capture the astonishing dynamic range of the ensemble. And there are recordings, too numerous to mention, that are just flat out exciting to listen to and stunning in their beauty.
Why didn’t Koussevitzky and the Boston Symphony Orchestra make records until three years after the advent of electrical recording in 1925? We need look no further than the turmoil the orchestra faced over the previous decade. With the arrest of conductor Karl Muck in March of 1918 (on overblown charges of sympathy toward the German war effort), many of the BSO musicians from Germany and central Europe departed in protest at the end of that season, prompting an influx of new players the following fall. In March 1920, the orchestra went on strike over wages and lack of union representation, and fully a third of the orchestra was fired on the spot.
With the survival of the orchestra in question, more than a few retired musicians returned to the fold, perhaps in a bid to secure their pensions going forward. Among them were cellist Alwin Schroeder, who first joined in 1891 and was principal for many seasons as well as being a member of the Kneisel Quartet; and violist John C. Mullaly, who joined the BSO in 1884 and was conductor of the Boston Pops in 1886. From Koussevitzky’s first appearance in October 1924 through November 1928, when the first recordings were made, thirty-seven players were replaced, including Schroeder and Mullaly. When the first Koussevitzky/BSO recordings were issued, the conductor said to the young record critic R.D. Darrell (one may read between the lines), “Ravel’s Daphne is very hard to play. The orchestra must know the music perfectly, and even then, it is very difficult. Petrouchka too… very difficult music. But for four years, I have worked with the orchestra and now…you shall hear. I am very pleased with the records, very pleased.”
The recordings from November 1928 through October 1930, spanning less than two years, form the first period of Koussevitzky’s legacy. Of the sixty 78 rpm sides, nearly half featured living composers, including Stravinsky, Ravel, and Prokofiev, with nine sides featuring Ravel’s wonderful orchestrations, including Mussorgsky’s Pictures at an Exhibition, an orchestration Koussevitzky commissioned and for which he had exclusive performing and recording rights for seven years.
Many of these recordings were remade in later years: Ravel’s Daphnis and Mother Goose, Haydn’s Surprise Symphony, Prokofiev’s Classical Symphony and excerpts from the opera Love for Three Oranges, and Satie’s Gymnopédie No. 1 (in Debussy’s orchestration). Comparing the early recordings with their later remakes is fascinating. The Satie and the final movement of the Ravel Mother Goose (“Le Jardin féerique”) are both vastly slower in the earlier recordings, the latter coming very close to running into the label on its 78 disc.
With the onset of the Depression, virtually all recording activity, including that of the BSO, was curtailed. This provided RCA Victor’s prime competitor, Columbia, an opportunity to poach Victor’s now-fallow roster. The company took on a significant technical challenge: capturing a new symphony from an American composer, Roy Harris. They would not have a recording session, would record it live as part of a Carnegie Hall concert of February 4, 1934. This was not a simple matter of hitting “record” on a tape deck; one needed at least an alternating pair of huge disc cutting lathes to cut each master, each lasting a mere four minutes or so. Columbia did not get off to a good start; the opening timpani strikes were missed and the side changes were not smooth. But it was the first commercial recording of a symphony by an American composer, and a release was allowed to go ahead, warts and all.
RCA Victor got the wake-up call with the Harris recording, and within a year, the company was back at Symphony Hall with much fanfare. Noticeable advancements had been made since they had last visited Boston, and one of the recording sessions was broadcast live on NBC.
https://archive.org/details/bostonsymphony193435bost/page/576/mode/2up
The records themselves were released with great fanfare. Strauss’s Also sprach Zarathustra was recorded complete for the first time, and contained “the loudest crescendo ever recorded,” according to the RCA Victor publicity of May 1935. It was regarded as the benchmark rendition for two decades. The January 1935 sessions also produced two works that were standbys with Koussevitzky, Sibelius’s Second Symphony and Mendelssohn Symphony No. 4, Italian.
Nearly another year passed before RCA Victor again returned to Boston. But the sessions of early May 1936 were astonishingly productive. Perhaps the departure of two of the label’s major partnerships, Arturo Toscanini from the New York Philharmonic and Leopold Stokowski from the Philadelphia Orchestra, turned RCA Victor to Boston and Koussevitzky with renewed energy. More than 30 sides were cut in just 3 sessions, May 4th, 6th, and 8th, 1936, capturing Koussevitzky/BSO at their finest, including a Tchaikovsky Fourth Symphony, a Liszt Mephisto Waltz No. 1, and a Sibelius Pohjola’s Daughter unrivaled until Colin Davis returned to the score some 40 years later. These sessions were shoehorned into a busy schedule. May 6th was Opening Night for the Boston Pops that year, making the accomplishment of these discs even more impressive. Another 30 sides came in December 28-30, 1936, renditions with such fire and passion that they put many a modern performance to shame, especially Tchaikovsky’s Romeo and Juliet and the Sibelius Fifth Symphony. Koussevitzky and the BSO’s accomplishment is all the more noteworthy as the vast majority of the sides were dispatched with just a single take.
Friday, March 26, 1937, marked a significant milestone in recorded history: the first complete recording of Bach’s St. Matthew Passion. It was captured in concert at Symphony Hall; the audience was asked not to applaud in between numbers.
https://archive.org/details/bostonsymphonyo193637bost/page/n1261/mode/2up
The resulting records were issued in three volumes, totaling 27 discs (53 sides) in a package weighing some 35 pounds.
Symphony Hall’s celebrated, phenomenal acoustics were not ideal for recording purposes. During Koussevitzky’s tenure, Symphony Hall, thanks to its proximity to Boston’s public trolley system, was provided with DC power, while RCA Victor’s amplifiers and disc cutters used AC (alternating current). In lieu of unreliable electric motors, to run the turntables on the mastering lathes, a system of weights and pulleys was used in the stairwells of Symphony Hall. This created a problem for the sessions of December 1937, the first with violinist Jascha Heifetz. Two concertos were recorded: the premiere recording of the Prokofiev Concerto No. 2 and Brahms’s Violin Concerto. However, the turntables spun at 80.6 rpm instead of the fairly standard 78 rpm. This meant that on playback at 78 rpm, the Brahms would be in something well flat of D major. It was decided not to release the familiar Brahms and to re-record it the following year. The Prokofiev, since there was nothing to compare it to, was issued as is (in a key well flat of G minor). Still, it had no competition for decades. These sessions also included a Prokofiev Lieutenant. Kijé Suite that has a stunning dynamic range for the period.
Buoyed by the success of recording the St. Matthew Passion, RCA Victor brought their equipment to record Beethoven’s Missa Solemnis in concert in April 1938. Had all gone as planned, the session would have sported several recording debuts: baritone Mack Harrell, the young organist E. Power Biggs, and, in the Harvard-Radcliffe Chorus, a student by the name of Leonard Bernstein. Alas, switching the recording lathes during the lengthy movements meant some critical music was lost, and the recordings were scrapped. They tried again in December 1938, recording two performances (with Biggs the organist after all). The result was another important choral masterpiece that had no competition for a dozen years. That same week, Koussevitzky and the BSO made several other significant recordings: their first of Aaron Copland’s music, his El Salón México; Brahms’s Fourth Symphony; and Debussy’s La Mer, without question the finest of the 78 rpm era, one that makes compelling listening today.
The sessions of November 6-8, 1939, produced an amazing set of discs. We have an important American symphony receiving its recording premiere, Roy Harris’s Third (which Koussevitzky and the BSO had premiered the previous February), arias featuring soprano Dorothy Maynor (whom Koussevitzky championed consistently), Harl McDonald’s San Juan Capistrano (recorded just days after its world premiere), and an energetic Schumann Spring Symphony. But special attention should be given to Sibelius’s Tapiola, which, more than half a century later, the legendary Finnish conductor Paavo Berglund cited as a major influence on his musical development.
Something of a shadow must have hung over the sessions of March 18-20, 1940. James Petrillo of the American Federation of Musicians was pressuring RCA Victor to end its activities with the non-union Boston Symphony, a ban that was effected as of Labor Day 1940. What Koussevitzky selected for these “farewell” sessions was characteristically bold: a still rarely heard Mozart Symphony (No. 34, K.338); the first (and for decades the only) recording of the recently deceased “Boston Six” composer Arthur Foote’s Serenade for Strings, the first recording of Stravinsky’s Capriccio for piano and orchestra with the wonderful Puerto Rican pianist Jesús María Sanromá, and the premiere recording of Howard Hanson’s Third Symphony (given its concert premiere by the BSO the previous November). The sessions ended with Grieg’s brief “The Last Spring.” (Concluding this incredible week of recording at Symphony Hall, during March 22-24 Arthur Fiedler and the Boston Pops made the first recording of Gershwin’s Concerto in F with Sanromá, along with some 40 other sides. As part of the BSO, Fiedler and the Pops were also barred from recording by the AFM. Although the BSO ban was lifted after its musicians unionized in late 1942, the AFM at that point prohibited recording nationwide in a dispute over royalty payments. Orchestra recording resumed only in late 1944.)
The return of Koussevitzky and the Boston Symphony to RCA Victor produced a whirlwind of activity. From November 22nd to 28th, 1944, were produced, among other items, the Fifth Symphonies of both Tchaikovsky and Beethoven and the first-ever recording of Berlioz’s viola concerto Harold in Italy, featuring soloist William Primrose. They returned just over a month later, on January 2 and 3, 1945, with Brahms’s Third and Mozart’s 39th symphonies, plus a new Schubert Unfinished (this time spread over 6 sides instead of the previous 5). April 23-25 produced some 28 sides of Rachmaninoff, Ravel, Richard Strauss, Walter Piston, Dmitri Shostakovich, and Randall Thompson. This six-month period produced an amazing 78 sides, plus another 14 sides of material that was not released during Koussevitzky’s lifetime.
1945 was something of a watershed year. Following the prolific January and April sessions, in August 1945 RCA Victor journeyed for the first time to Tanglewood (the BSO’s summer home since 1937) to make records. There were limitations that summer, for sure, as the BSO did not perform at the Shed due to World War II. But beginning in 1944, Koussevitzky had initiated chamber orchestra concerts at Tanglewood’s Theatre-Concert Hall, while the main ensemble performed at Boston’s Charles River Esplanade with Fiedler as the Boston Pops. The Theatre-Concert Hall performances became the Bach-Mozart concerts that opened the Tanglewood season for some three decades. For RCA Victor, in spite of having to lug their equipment up to the Berkshires, Tanglewood represented an opportunity to make records when no one else was in season. So in summer 1945, Koussevitzky and the BSO recorded two of Bach’s four Orchestral Suites and two of the six Brandenburg Concertos. From that point, nearly half of the Koussevitzky/BSO recordings were made at Tanglewood, and with the notable exception of 1947, the majority of them featured music of Bach and Mozart.
Two very productive sessions took place in the following season, both of them with important first recordings of Prokofiev and Copland. In October 1945 RCA Victor captured the orchestral suite of Copland’s Appalachian Spring and Prokofiev’s Romeo and Juliet Suite No. 2, well as a Beethoven Eroica. In February 1946 they tackled two recently minted works, Prokofiev’s Symphony No. 5 and Copland’s Lincoln Portrait.
(The Prokofiev symphony must have given Koussevitzky a measure of pride. When the war was raging, Prokofiev had made a request to the Boston Symphony conductor for orchestral score paper. Koussevitzky sent one of his assistants to Boston Music for a stack of it, and had it shipped off to the USSR. The manuscript paper was duly returned to Boston inscribed with the Fifth Symphony in time for its American premiere under Koussevitzky’s direction in November 1945.)
Summer 1946 at Tanglewood saw the remaining two of the Bach Orchestral Suites, two more Brandenburgs, and Mozart’s Symphony No. 33. The sessions of the 1946-47 season, in the late fall and in April, netted more than 30 sides of Shostakovich, Haydn, Ravel, Wagner, Weber, Brahms, and Beethoven.
The Tanglewood sessions of 1947 sent RCA Victor from the Theatre-Concert Hall to the Shed main stage, with decidedly mixed results. Rather than just Bach and Mozart, the full BSO recorded Ravel’s Boléro and Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony. Issues with electrical power at the Shed and the venue’s acoustics resulted in rather dry recorded sound. Recording in the Shed was not attempted again in that era.
Probably anticipating the recording ban of 1948, a recording session was scheduled on November 25, 1947—not at Symphony Hall, but at Carnegie Hall—of Prokofiev’s Classical Symphony and Mendelssohn’s Italian. RCA Victor producer Macklin Marrow was overjoyed with the results, declaring to Koussevitzky that they were his best recordings ever. Indeed, the renditions of the symphonies reveal the orchestra in fabulous form, the 73-year-old conductor’s tempos as energetic as ever. Technically, they not only capture the higher frequencies not heard in earlier decades, but a dynamic range possible in these optical recordings that was wider than the more compressed dynamics of RCA’s later magnetic tape recordings of 1949 and beyond.
The last sessions take us to the final days of Koussevitzky’s tenure at Symphony Hall. In April 1949 he recorded a new Tchaikovsky Fourth Symphony (“replacing” the one of 1936), and Wagner’s Siegfried Idyll and the Prelude to Act I of Lohengrin. All of Koussevitzky’s sessions after this, except the final one, were back at Tanglewood. August 1949 brought us an absolutely sensational Tchaikovsky Serenade for Strings. The last movement especially shows the lower strings in virtuosic form. August 1950 was highlighted by a new recording of Peter and the Wolf, narrated by former First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt.
Koussevitzky’s health, a challenge toward the end of his BSO tenure, was now failing. He led his last concerts as BSO Music Director in August 1949 and was succeeded in the post by Charles Munch that fall. Koussevitzky’s last appearances at Symphony Hall were in the late fall of 1950. RCA Victor tape machines (stopping every five minutes or so to accommodate the 45 rpm records that RCA was featuring in the “battle of the speeds”—from which Columbia emerged victorious with their preferred 33 1/3) recorded a Sibelius Second Symphony, ending, as it had a decade earlier, with Grieg’s elegiac “The Last Spring.”
Among his many activities over the years, Brian Bell produced two CDs featuring performances of Serge Koussevitzky and the Boston Symphony for BSO Classics.