Piano Concerto No. 1 in G minor, Opus 25
Jakob Ludwig Felix Mendelssohn was born in Hamburg on February 3, 1809, and died in Leipzig on November 4, 1847. (Bartholdy was the name of his mother’s brother Jakob, who had changed his own name from Salomon, taking Bartholdy from the previous owner of a piece of real estate he had bought in Berlin. It was he who persistently urged the family’s conversion to Lutheranism, the name Bartholdy being added to Mendelssohn—to distinguish the Protestant Mendelssohns from the Jewish ones—when Felix’s father converted in 1822, the children already having been baptized in 1816.) Mendelssohn sketched his Piano Concerto No. 1 in Munich in fall 1830 and completed the score the following year. Mendelssohn himself was soloist for the first performance, which took place at the Odeon in Munich on October 17, 1831.
In addition to the solo piano, the score calls for 2 each of flutes, oboes, clarinets, and bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani, and strings (first and second violins, violas, cellos, and double basses).
Mendelssohn was in love. We owe the existence of Piano Concerto No. 1 in G minor to a youthful infatuation of the composer with the young pianist Delphine von Schauroth (1813-1887). Mendelssohn had first met her in March 1825 in Paris where she performed at a private soirée. Schauroth was a child prodigy, not yet 12 years old at the time, who garnered praise for her unexpectedly mature interpretations of the composers of the day—Beethoven, Hummel, Czerny, Chopin. But it was five years later, when Mendelssohn’s and Schauroth’s paths crossed again in Munich in 1830, that the composer seriously fell for the now 17-year-old, smitten in equal measure by her musical talent, her winsome personality, and her beauty. Felix wrote a letter to his sister Fanny from Munich at that time: “As for me, I go to the galleries day after day, and twice a week I visit Schauroth in the morning, where I stay for a long time; we flirt terribly.” With two of his other (male) friends he was less bashful; he told them outright that he was head over heels in love and considering marriage. However, the relationship ended rather suddenly when Mendelssohn left Munich for Italy.
Mendelssohn made no secret about his feelings for Schauroth. Robert Schumann would write home a little later: “[Mendelssohn] wrote the piano concerto in G minor, as he told me, in few days (I believe he said in three days) in Munich. He thought of Delphine von Schauroth, the excellent and very attractive pianist, as someone who might be dangerous to him.” The piano concerto indeed bears a dedication to Schauroth, as does Mendelssohn’s famous Venetian Gondolier’s Song in G minor, from the Songs without Words, Op. 19, No. 6, which he composed after leaving Munich. Considering how seldom Mendelssohn gave his works explicit dedications, there is no doubt that Schauroth had deeply affected the young Felix.
Schumann is correct that Mendelssohn had enthusiastically penned the piano concerto in a matter of days—and the exuberant work instantly became a rousing success. Mendelssohn would perform the solo part himself at any opportunity he found. The concerto was universally praised by the critics, who admired its “inexhaustible new effects,” its “original[ity], almost to overflowing,” as well as its “difficulties that none but the author could master.” It took the European concert halls by storm.
After a while, however, the concerto would fall victim to its own success. The brilliant work was simply played too often, and its audiences were starting to get bored. The French composer Hector Berlioz, who would often wield a sharp pen in his critical writings vis-à-vis his colleagues and competitors, wrote a satire in which the Mendelssohn concerto is performed so often at a conservatoire competition that the Érard piano eventually starts playing the music all by itself unstoppably, over and over again, getting louder and faster, and careening out of control. By the end of the 19th century, the German music critic Oscar Bie would complain that the concerto was performed in concerts ad nauseam. Audiences had grown tired of it.
One other feature may have contributed to the shifting moods in response to Mendelssohn’s concerto. The virtuosic style of the composition orients itself by the composers that were popular at the time, in the early 19th century. Showpieces such as Carl Maria von Weber’s Konzertstück for piano and orchestra, Op. 79, Johann Nepomuk Hummel’s fantasia Oberon’s Magic Horn for piano and orchestra, Op. 116, or Beethoven’s Choral Fantasy, Op. 80—in other words, works heard relatively rarely nowadays—provided the background to Mendelssohn’s work for those early audiences. As those works slowly fell out of favor, and a more muscular kind of virtuosity took over in later Romanticism, it was Mendelssohn’s G minor concerto that remained in the repertoire but appeared increasingly out of place as the century wore on.
From our modern perspective, meanwhile, it is easier to identify with the unbridled enthusiasm with which those early audiences greeted this concerto. It is hard not to get swept up by its (seemingly) effortless brilliance, which, in one continuous breeze, wasting no time and picking up right from the first note, moves from the dramatic fervor of the first movement to the effervescent virtuosity of the final movement.
The fast-and-furious approach to composition that the enamored Mendelssohn took when he dashed off his concerto in merely a few days, also found expression in the shape of the work. The continuity of the three movements, all performed attacca, i.e., without interruption, which was highlighted by many commentators as a novel feature of the work, gives vivid audible expression of the storm and stress of its conception. While the concerto counts as a cyclic work, meaning that thematic elements return across movements, it is perhaps unsurprising that the music does not show a great deal of motivic coherence and that its formal structures are relatively unruly. (Formal and motivic intricacies typically require careful working out, often in many rounds of drafts and sketches.) As a skilled composer, Mendelssohn would have been perfectly capable of both, but they were simply not relevant dimensions in this work. What mattered instead was the overflowing creative spirit bubbling with ever new ideas and materials that would immediately capture its audiences and sweep them off their feet.
The opening movement dispenses with the conventional extended orchestral opening and begins in medias res, bursting with energy, with a short orchestral flourish to raise the curtain for the solo instrument. The piano picks up the feverish pitch in a short prelude that soon evolves into the main theme for the movement, for which the orchestra joins in. The stormy undertones that prevail during this movement only dissipate slowly, as the piano approaches the sunnier second theme, first in the expected key of B-flat major but soon swerving into the remoter region of D-flat major. The whole second theme is harmonically flighty and, flitting away in ever new extensions and digressions, evades any attempts to pin it down. Gradually the mood of nervous agitation returns, and before we know it, the first theme with all its dramatically pent-up energy returns. There is no solo cadenza, there is barely a central development section worth its name—the Molto allegro con fuoco drives forward with relentless passion, almost too eager to reach the end. When the portentous first theme returns this time around, however, solo piano and orchestra engage in a heated exchange, with the orchestra punctuating and harshly interrupting the piano’s pleading melody. Only gradually is the smooth dialog between the sides reestablished. The movement does not formally end but transitions smoothly, after a short fanfare, into a pensive recitative passage for the solo instrument that gives way to the following movement.
The slow movement, a Beethovenian Andante in E major, is a meditation on a luminous cavatina theme, bathed in the radiant warmth of the lower strings. A certain resemblance in mood and style has been noted to the Irish tune “Last Rose of Summer,” on which Mendelssohn had written his set of piano variations, Opus 15. This theme is taken over by the piano and developed in an extended solo passage. A contrasting middle section retains the guileless contemplative tone and continues to sound the quieter hues on the palette of virtuosity that Mendelssohn has turned to in this movement.
While the dreamy slow movement, unlike the stormy opening Allegro, does formally come to an end, there is no time to waste: the fanfare from the transition into the slow movement returns and rouses us for the delightful quicksilver wit of the final movement, now in G major, the bright parallel key of the broody G-minor first movement. The main theme, an invention of pure Mendelssohnian grace, is brimming with pearly arpeggios and scales. This theme, presented in many breathtaking variations, dominates the Presto, which can almost be heard as a perpetuum mobile, an unstoppable showcase for the pianist’s bravura. Right before the end of the movement, a reminiscence of the second theme from the first movement, a distant memory of darker times, stops the solo instrument in its tracks, but no matter: the boundless joyous energy returns just as soon, and the movement closes with a veritable explosion of pianistic pyrotechnics.
We would be remiss not to disclose the aftermath of Mendelssohn’s relationship with Delphine von Schauroth, who was, after all, such an important part of the inspiration behind this concerto. They did in fact see each other again in London, only a few years later. At that time Delphine was married, unhappily it seems, to Edwin Hill-Handley, an English barrister and enthusiastic cricketer. Considering her marital status, Mendelssohn was noticeably reluctant to overstep any boundaries and avoided taking up further contact with her. While his sister Fanny visited Delphine, now divorced, in Munich in 1839, that awkward London encounter was, as far as we know, the last time Felix saw her.
Alexander Rehding
Alexander Rehding is Fanny Peabody Professor of Music at Harvard University. A scholar focusing on sound media and 19th-century music, he has authored books including Music and Monumentality; Alien Listening: The Voyager Golden Record and Music from Earth; and Beethoven’s Symphony No. 9.
The first American performance of Mendelssohn’s G minor Piano Concerto took place on January 17, 1846, when H.C. Timm was soloist with the Philharmonic Society of New York, Ureli Corelli Hill conducting. Boston first heard the concerto on December 9, 1848, at a Boston Musical Fund Society concert with George H. Webb conducting and John Liptrott Hatton as soloist.
The first Boston Symphony performance of Mendelssohn’s G minor Concerto was given by soloist Eugenia Castellano on January 12, 1893, in New York City’s Chickering Hall with Arthur Nikisch conducting.